Saturday, July 21, 2012

Chemical Networks (Triple Header!)




A back-to-back-to-back (!) set of three papers in Angewandte Chemie from Bartosz Grzybowski and co-workers. All three articles concern the development of Chemical Networks and their application in synthetic chemistry, of which more later. It is often said that the realm of synthesis is both art and science, however, the wealth of empirical observations made over centuries of making molecules underpin the field. As Grzybowski remarks here, “it is simply beyond cognition of any individual human to understand and analyze all this collective chemical knowledge”, and most chemists already search online synthesis databases to perform individual steps, but perhaps the role of automated computational synthetic route selection, and reaction design is set to grow? Also see Dean Tantillo's recent post on CCH.

Grzybowksi’s group has constructed a network of organic chemistry (NOC) from reactions in the chemical literature since 1779 until present day: reactants and products are represented by nodes in this graph and known chemical interconversions by edges. From this NOC containing seven million reactions, the first paper of the series seeks to discover new ways of performing consecutive reactions in the same vessel (so-called “one pot” reactions). From known reactions that interconvert A to B and B to C, the authors have coded filters that check for compatability between solvents, reagents, catalysts etc so that the two steps may be performed in the same reaction vessel, thus creating a novel way to prepare C from A in one step. Typically synthetic organic protocols are the result of much tinkering and optimization studies in the lab: in contrast the NOC predictions have yield a number of two, three and four step one-pot reactions that give moderate to good yields without any human optimization.
In the second paper the group turn their attention to designing “optimal” reaction pathways to synthesise a given target molecule. Again the NOC is used, this time to propagate backwards from the target via an initial synthetic plan to starting materials. A Metropolis Monte Carlo algorithm is used to randomly sample alternative routes in order to minimize a penalty function associated with the cost of performing each step. Impressively this approach has been used already by a synthesis company to reduce their costs. Additional costs such as waste disposal or energy costs associated with heating/cooling are undoubtedly important for chemistry on the process scale, and perhaps these could be incorporated in future implementations of the optimization.
The third application of a chemical network considers the synthesis of chemical warfare agents. Reaction networks are explored starting from commonly available household chemicals. Thankfully the paper is careful not to disclose any of the synthetic steps involved, and the authors propose strengthening existing regulation of substances by not only regulating single molecules but also combinations of reagents that have been ranked according to game theory as more likely to be used. 

Friday, July 20, 2012

A Paramagnetic Bonding Mechanism for Diatomics in Strong Magnetic Fields

Kai K. Lange, E. I. Tellgren, M. R. Hoffmann and T. Helgaker Science 2012, 337, 327 (Paywall)

A new bonding mechanism
As chemists we are familiar with two types of strong bonds occurring between atoms, covalent and ionic. This paper shows that when very strong magnetic fields (of the order of 105 T) are applied, a third bonding mechanism arrises. Helgaker and co-workers term this perpendicular paramagnetic bonding.


Binding triplet H2
Whilst previous Hartree-Fock calculations have shown that the lowest triplet state of H2 becomes bound in strong magnetic fields, this investigation uses the recently developed LONDON code to demonstrate the same phenomena at the Full-CI level. Similar calculations (again, with a very strong magnetic field) on the triplet state of He2 show a considerable strengthening of the interaction between the constituent atoms.

The nature of this bonding
By examining the behaviour of the molecular orbitals under different orientations relative to the external magnetic field, the authors note a stabilisation of antibonding orbitals in the perpendicular orientation, leading to a new type of bonding interaction. Although the potential of a new chemical bonding mechanism is undoubtably exciting, the magnetic fields required are beyond those that can be currently generated in a lab. However, such fields are present on some stellar objects and the findings of this paper are likely to aid in the spectroscopy of such bodies.

Thursday, July 5, 2012

Dynamic Origin of the Stereoselectivity of a Nucleophilic Substitution Reaction

Bogle, X. S.; Singleton, D. A. Org. Lett., 2012, 14, 2528-2531 (Paywall)
Contributed by Steven Bachrach.
Reposted from Computational Organic Chemistry with permission


I think most organic chemists hold dear to their hearts the notion that selectivity is due to crossing over different transition states. Readers of my book and this blog know of the many examples where this notion simply is not true (see here). This post discusses yet another example taking place in a seemingly simple reaction.


Singleton has examined the nucleophilic substitution reaction of 1 with sodium tolylsulfide.1 The mono substitution gives potentially two different stereoproducts 2 and 3. The experimental ratio of these products 2:3 is 81:19. (Note that things are a bit more complicated because disubstitution can also occur, but this has been factored into the product ratio.)
Based on previous literature, this reaction is likely to proceed in a concerted fashion, and so one might anticipate running computations to locate a transition state leading to 2 and a transition state leading to3. In fact, Singleton finds six different TSs (the lowest energy TS 4 is shown in Figure 1), all within 2 kcal mol-1 of each other at PCM(ethanol)/B3LYP/6-31+G**. However, the intrinsic reaction coordinate going forward from each of these six TSs leads solely to 2; no TS could be located that connects to 3! (Computations were also performed at PCM(ethanol)/M06-2x/6-31+G** which give very similar results.) Classical transition state theory would lead one to conclude that only 2 should be formed, inconsistent with experiment.

4

5
Figure 1. PCM/B3LYP/6-31+G** optimized structures of TSs 4 and 5.

Furthermore, no intermediate could be located. This is consistent with a concerted mechanism. A second transition state was located which interconverts 2 and 3 with the involvement of a chloride – a sort of addition/rotation/elimination process. This TS 5 is also shown in Figure 1.

A direct dynamics study was performed, and 197 trajectories were computed. Of these, 185 trajectories went to product: 156 to 2 and 29 to 3, for a ratio of 84:16 – in amazing agreement with experiment! The product selectivity is due entirely to dynamic effects. In fact, it is one vibrational mode that dictates the product distribution. Essentially, the nature of the rotation about the C=C bond differentiates the eventual route, with a clockwise rotation leading always to 2 and a counterclockwise rotation leading about a third of the time to 3.

References

(1) Bogle, X. S.; Singleton, D. A. "Dynamic Origin of the Stereoselectivity of a Nucleophilic Substitution Reaction," Org. Lett., 2012, 14, 2528-2531, DOI: 10.1021/ol300817a.



Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.

Saturday, June 23, 2012

Accurate Predictions of Nonpolar Solvation Free Energies Require Explicit Consideration of Binding-Site Hydration



ab initio prediction of protein-ligand binding free energies
Fast computers and clever algorithms have made it possible to calculate protein-ligand binding energies ab initio using levels of theory that have been shown to give accurate gas phase binding energies.  PCM or closely related approaches like COSMO, that are the solvation methods of choice for most ab initio studies have now also been implemented in a way that allows for calculations on protein size systems.  However, the combined use of ab initio and PCM (without any further fitting) typically results in absolute protein-ligand binding energies that bear little resemblance to experimental values.

Trouble from an unexpected source
Given the complexity of the problem there are of course many possible sources of error but in 2010 Ryde and co-workers$^1$ identified one major source of error that surprised me.  They used thermodynamic integration (TI) to compute the non-polar solvation free energy contribution $(\Delta G_{np})$ to the binding free energy of benzene to T4 lysozyme mutant L99A and showed that the $\Delta G_{np}$ computed by PCM was off by almost 50 kJ/mol!  For comparison, an approach based on the solvent accessible surface area (SASA) came within 4 kJ/mol of the TI result.

As both experiment and calculations suggested that the binding pocket was solvent free in the ligand-free state, the PCM energy of the apoprotein was recomputed with a "dummy" benzene molecule in the pocket to yield a $\Delta G_{np}$ energy within 2 kJ/mol of the TI results.

Exposed binding pockets are even trickier
In the current paper Ryde and co-workers perform similar comparisons for four additional protein-ligand complexes with varying degrees of solvent exposure of the empty binding binding pocket.  The dummy-ligand approach works surprisingly well for the two proteins with the most buried binding pockets ($\Delta G_{np}$ are within 2.4 kJ/mol of the TI results).  "Surprisingly" because both experiment and MD calculations indicate that several water molecules are displaced from the binding pocket upon ligand binding.  

The dummy-ligand approach does not work well for the more expose binding pockets with deviations from TI-results as large as 73 kJ/mol for galectin-3.  While this is not too surprising, the traditional (non-dummy ligand approach) approach is not much better, with an error of 58 kJ/mol for galectin-3.  For comparison the SASA-based prediction is in error by 28 kJ/mol: better, but not really useful.  Clearly, treating water molecules bound in very solvent-exposed pockets as a continuum is not a good approximation with the current models of non-polar solvation.  

New approaches needed
The question now is whether a hybrid PCM/explicit solvation approach is needed or whether the problem can be fixed by reformulating and/or parameterizing the non-polar solvation energy terms.  For the altter approach the authors indicate that the cavitation term may present a particular challenge as it includes the entropy change due to the water molecules displaced upon binding. 

References
1. S. Genheden, J. Kongsted, P. Söderhjelm, and U. Ryde J. Chem Theory, Comput 2010, 6, 3558. DOI: 10.1021/ct100272s


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.  

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Tunnelling control of chemical reactions – the organic chemist’s perspective

Ley, D.; Gerbig, D.; Schreiner, P. R. Org. Biomol. Chem., 2012, 10, 3781 (Paywall)
Contributed by Steven Bachrach.
Reposted from Computational Organic Chemistry with permission

Schreiner has written a very nice review of the role of tunneling in organic chemistry.1 This includes tunneling in the conformations of carboxylic acids and in hydrogen abstractions. But the major emphasis is on his own group’s contributions regarding tunneling on a variety of hydroxycarbenes (see these posts: cyclopropylhydroxycarbene, methylhydroxycarbene, phenylhydroxycarbene, dihydroxycarbene, and hydroxymethylene). This led to the development of a third means for controlling reactions: not just kinetic and thermodynamic control, but tunneling control as well.

Recommended reading for anyone interested in learning how quantum mechanical tunneling can have very real-world chemical consequences.



Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.

Accurate ab Initio Spin Densities

Katharina Boguslawski, Konrad H. Marti, Örs Legeza and Markus Reiher Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2012, 8, 1970 (Paywall)

The spin density problem
Obtaining accurate spin density distributions and predicting the correct ground state from a number of close lying states of different spin is a challenging problem in quantum chemistry, particularly when transition metal systems are considered. This paper highlights how density-matrix renomarlization group1 (DMRG) based methods can be used to calculate spin density distributions for molecules that are too large to be treated by complete-active-space self-consistent-field (CASSCF) methods. What I found particularly exciting is the prospect of using DMRG results in the benchmarking and development of new density functionals.

Benchmarking DMRG
The electronic structure of a simple model system of iron nitrosyl is manipulated by surrounding it with point-charges (simulating ligands), adjusting the position of these charges means the system becomes either single- or multi-reference. The results convincingly show how DMRG can converge to a CASSCF(7,7) reference spin density by controlling the number of reference active-system states in the DMRG. The DMRG calculations were carried out using the Reiher group's Qc-Dmrg-ETH code.

Spin densities for large active spaces and comparison to DFT
A problem arrises in CASSCF when the number of active electrons and orbitals required to correctly describe the system becomes too large (this article suggests 18 electrons in 18 orbitals as a practical limit). The paper goes on to show that much larger active spaces are possible with DMRG and, more importantly, that the spin density converges very quickly both with respect to active space and the number of active-system states. The resulting spin densities are then compared to a number of common density functionals, none of which accurately reproduces the DMRG result. Whilst DMRG calculations are not yet commonplace in the computational chemistry community, this paper convinces me that they will have an important role to play in solving the spin density problem.

References
(1) For an introduction to DMRG see: Chan, G. K.-L.; Dorando, J. J.; Ghosh, D.; Hachmann. J.; Neuscamman, E.; Wang, H.;Yanai, T. An Introduction to the Density Matrix Renormalization Group Ansatz in Quantum Chemistry. In Frontiers in Quantum Systems in Chemistry and Physics, 1st ed.; Wilson, S., Grout, P. J.; Maruani, J., Delgado-Barrio, G., Piecuch, P., Eds.; Springer: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2008; Vol. 18, pp 49-65. arXiv:0711.1398v1.

Tuesday, June 5, 2012

Jailbreaking Benzene Dimers

A. Yu. Rogachev, X.-D. Wen, R. Hoffmann Journal of the American Chemical Society 2012, 134, 8062. (Paywall)
Contributed by Steven Bachrach.
Reposted from Computational Organic Chemistry with permission


Hoffmann1 reports on a number of new benzene dimer structures, notably 5-8, whose RIJCOSX-MP2/cc-pVTZ2 structures are shown in Figure 1. A few of these new dimers are only somewhat higher in energy than the known dimers 1-4. The energies of these dimers, relative to two isolated benzene molecules, are listed in Table 1.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8
Figure 1. RIJCOSX-MP2/cc-pVTZ optimized geometries of 1-8.
Table 1. Energy (kcal mol-1) of the dimers relative to two benzene molecules and activation energy for reversion to two benzene molecules.

Compound
Erel
Eact
1
50.9
29
2
49.9

3
38.2
9
4
58.7
19
5
71.9
30
6
49.9
36
7
60.8
27
8
98.8
28

The energy for reversion of the isomers 5-8 to two isolated benzene molecules is calculated to be fairly large, and so they should be stable relative to that decomposition mode. They also examined a series of other decomposition modes, including [1,5]-hydrogen migration, all of which had barriers of 21 kcal mol-1 or greater, retrocyclization ([2+2]), for which they could not locate transition states, electrocyclic ring opening (Cope), with barriers of at least 17 kcal mol-1 and dimerization – some of which had relatively small enthalpic barriers of 4-5 kcal mol-1. However, the dimerizations all have very unfavorable entropic activation barriers.
So, the conclusion is that all of the novel dimers (4-8) can be reasonable expected to hang around for some time and therefore are potential synthetic targets.

References

(1) Rogachev, A. Yu.; Wen, X.-D.; Hoffmann, R. "Jailbreaking Benzene Dimers," J.
Am. Chem. Soc.
, 2012, 134, 8062-8065, DOI:10.1021/ja302597r
(2) Kossmann, S.; Neese, F. "Efficient Structure Optimization with Second-Order Many-Body Perturbation Theory: The RIJCOSX-MP2 Method," J. Chem. Theory Comput., 2010, 6, 2325-2338, DOI:10.1021/ct100199k

InChIs

1: InChI=1S/C12H12/c1-2-6-10-9(5-1)11-7-3-4-8-12(10)11/h1-12H/t9-,10+,11-,12+
InChIKey=WMPWOGVJEXSFLI-UHFFFAOYSA-N
2: InChI=1S/C12H12/c1-2-6-10-9(5-1)11-7-3-4-8-12(10)11/h1-12H/t9-,10+,11+,12-
InChIKey=WMPWOGVJEXSFLI-IWDIQUIJSA-N
3: InChI=1S/C12H12/c1-2-4-12-10-7-5-9(6-8-10)11(12)3-1/h1-12H/t9?,10?,11-,12+
InChIKey=ONVDJSCNMCYFTI-CAODYFQJSA-N
4: InChI=1S/C12H12/c1-2-10-4-3-9(1)11-5-7-12(10)8-6-11/h1-12H
InChIKey=BCBHEUOKKNYIAT-UHFFFAOYSA-N
5: InChI=1S/C12H12/c1-2-6-10-9(5-1)11-7-3-4-8-12(10)11/h1-12H/t9-,10-,11+,12+/m1/s1
InChIKey=WMPWOGVJEXSFLI-WYUUTHIRSA-N
6: InChI=1S/C12H12/c1-2-4-12-10-7-5-9(6-8-10)11(12)3-1/h1-12H/t9?,10?,11-,12-/m0/s1
InChIKey=ONVDJSCNMCYFTI-QQFIATSDSA-N
7: InChI=1S/C12H12/c1-2-6-10-9(5-1)11-7-3-4-8-12(10)11/h1-12H/t9-,10-,11-,12+/m1/s1
InChIKey=WMPWOGVJEXSFLI-KKOKHZNYSA-N
8: InChI=1S/C12H12/c1-2-6-10-9(5-1)11-7-3-4-8-12(10)11/h1-12H/t9-,10-,11-,12-
InChIKey=WMPWOGVJEXSFLI-NQYKUJLISA-N