Showing posts with label barbatti. Show all posts
Showing posts with label barbatti. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 5, 2014

Ultrafast X-ray Auger probing of photoexcited molecular dynamics

McFarland, B. K.; Farrell, J. P.; Miyabe, S.; Tarantelli, F.; Aguilar, A.; Berrah, N.; Bostedt, C.; Bozek, J. D.; Bucksbaum, P. H.; Castagna, J. C.; Coffee, R. N.; Cryan, J. P.; Fang, L.; Feifel, R.; Gaffney, K. J.; Glownia, J. M.; Martinez, T. J.; Mucke, M.; Murphy, B.; Natan, A.; Osipov, T.; Petrović, V. S.; Schorb, S.; Schultz, T.; Spector, L. S.; Swiggers, M.; Tenney, I.; Wang, S.; White, J. L.; White, W.; Gühr, M. Nat Commun 2014, 5, doi:10.1038/ncomms5235.
Highlighted by Mario Barbatti

The deconvolution of nuclear and electronic ultrafast motions poses a great challenge for spectroscopic approaches and nonadiabatic dynamics simulations has been a valuable tool to help with this task.

But are dynamics simulations providing reliable information?

Take, for instance, thymine. The ultrafast dynamics of this molecule has been under debate for a decade. 

Thymine has the longest excited-state lifetime among the five canonical nucleobases in the gas phase. According to Ref. (1), after 267-nm excitation, thymine shows a double-exponential deactivation with 105-fs and 5.12-ps time constants. 

The long time constant, which has been assigned to the excited-state lifetime of thymine, was attributed at first to a trapping of the population in the S1 (nπ*) state after a quick relaxation from the initially excited S2 (ππ*) state (2) (see Fig. 1). 

As a second possibility, an independent study proposed that the deactivation occurred solely on the ππ* state, without any major influence of the nπ* state (3). In this case, the trapping site would be located at another region of the S1 surface at a minimum with ππ* character. 

Either way, from one of those S1 minima, thymine would take a few picoseconds to find the seam of conical intersections to the ground state, explaining its longer lifetime. 
Fig. 1 - After photoexcitation, how does thymine returns to the ground state?

This interpretation has been disputed since different sets of dynamics simulations at CASSCF level predicted that the S2 (ππ*) → S1 (nπ*) relaxation time itself occurs on a few picoseconds (4,5). Hence both, elongated S2 (ππ*) → S1 (nπ*) relaxation and then S1 (nπ*) trapping, would contribute to the long time constant.

This entangled story has gained another chapter with a curious twist (6): based on ultrafast X-ray Auger probe spectroscopy and simulations (ADC(2), CK-CIS), McFarland and co-authors found strong evidences that thymine excitation at 266 nm should populate the S1 (nπ*) state within only 200 fs, just like in the first proposal.

It makes possible that the S2 (ππ*) trapping was, after all, an artifact of dynamics simulations limited to CASSCF surfaces.

References
(1) Canuel, C.; Mons, M.; Piuzzi, F.; Tardivel, B.; Dimicoli, I.; Elhanine, M. J. Chem. Phys. 2005, 122, 074316-074316. doi:10.1063/1.1850469
(2) Perun, S.; Sobolewski, A. L.; Domcke, W. J. Phys. Chem. A 2006, 110, 13238-13244. doi:10.1021/jp0633897
(3) Merchán, M.; González-Luque, R.; Climent, T.; Serrano-Andrés, L.; Rodriuguez, E.; Reguero, M.; Pelaez, D. J. Phys. Chem. B 2006, 110, 26471-26476. doi:10.1021/jp066874a
(4) Hudock, H. R.; Levine, B. G.; Thompson, A. L.; Satzger, H.; Townsend, D.; Gador, N.; Ullrich, S.; Stolow, A.; Martínez, T. J. J. Phys. Chem. A 2007, 111, 8500-8508. doi:10.1021/jp0723665
(5) Szymczak, J. J.; Barbatti, M.; Soo Hoo, J. T.; Adkins, J. A.; Windus, T. L.; Nachtigallová, D.; Lischka, H. J. Phys. Chem. A 2009, 113, 12686-12693.doi:10.1021/jp905085x
(6) McFarland, B. K.; Farrell, J. P.; Miyabe, S.; Tarantelli, F.; Aguilar, A.; Berrah, N.; Bostedt, C.; Bozek, J. D.; Bucksbaum, P. H.; Castagna, J. C.; Coffee, R. N.; Cryan, J. P.; Fang, L.; Feifel, R.; Gaffney, K. J.; Glownia, J. M.; Martinez, T. J.; Mucke, M.; Murphy, B.; Natan, A.; Osipov, T.; Petrović, V. S.; Schorb, S.; Schultz, T.; Spector, L. S.; Swiggers, M.; Tenney, I.; Wang, S.; White, J. L.; White, W.; Gühr, M. Nat Commun 2014, 5, doi:10.1038/ncomms5235.

Friday, March 14, 2014

The V state of ethylene: valence bond theory takes up the challenge

Wu, W.; Zhang, H.; Braïda, B.; Shaik, S.; Hiberty, P., Theor. Chem. Acc. 2014, 133, 1-13
Highlighted by Mario Barbatti

The computation of the excitation from the ground state into the first singlet ππ* state of ethylene - or the N→V transition as it is known - has been a challenge for decades.1-4 Conventional molecular-orbital (MO) theories tend to overshoot the transition energy by far too much. A CASSCF (complete active space self-consistent field) computation in a 2-electrons/2-orbitals space with a modest basis set as the 6-31G*, for instance, predicts this transition to be 2.5 eV larger than the experimental value, 7.88 eV.

Far from being a simple curiosity restricted to ethylene, the difficulty for describing this type of state is overspread everywhere in organic photochemistry. The prediction of the Soret band in porphyrin, for example, will suffer from the same deficiencies, for the same reasons.

Two main factors contribute to the problem:
  • Lack of proper electron dynamic correlation: usually, dynamic correlation is computed after the CASSCF step via perturbative or configuration interaction (CI) methods. In the case of the N→V transition, the convergence is anomalously slow. Some hardcore calculations have employed 80 million configurations in the CI expansion to obtain acceptable energies.2       
  • Basis set effects: due to the ionic character of the V state, diffuse functions are essential to describe the molecular orbitals. However, the inclusion of diffuse functions also induces an artificial mixing of the V state with Rydberg states, which brings the the excitation energy closer to the experimental value by wrong reasons.

For decades, theoreticians have investigated the V state of ethylene with the most diverse methods. In 2009, Angeli showed that the dynamic response of the σ framework to the fluctuation of the π electrons is of central importance.3 It explains the reason underlying the poor convergence of the CI methods: in conventional methods, dynamic correlation is computed with a pre-optimized set of MOs, which does not include such σ-π dynamic mixing.

In this highlighted paper,4 Wu and co-workers systematically investigate the N→V transition using valence-bond (VB) methods. Two properties are taken into account, the transition energy and the spatial extension of the V state.With a clever sequence of calculations using different methods and levels, they showed the impact of several different factors to the predictions of the V state. 

Most impressive, they also showed that a compact set of only 5 valence bond structures (Fig. 1) is already enough to obtain a quantitatively accurate description of the N→V transition, just 0.13 eV above the experimental value. To achieve that result, however, each VB structure must have its own set of orbitals.

Fig. 1 - Set of VB structures for the computation of the N and V states in the (2,2) space. Reproduced from Ref.1.

References

(1) Bender, C. F.; Dunning Jr, T. H.; Schaefer III, H. F.; Goddard Iii, W. A.; Hunt, W. J., "Multiconfiguration wavefuntions for the lowest (ππ*) excited states of ethylene". Chem. Phys. Lett. 1972, 15, 171-178. doi: 10.1016/0009-2614(72)80143-X
(2) Müller, T.; Dallos, M.; Lischka, H., "The ethylene 11B1u V state revisited". J. Chem. Phys. 1999, 110, 7176-7184. doi: 10.1063/1.478621
(3) Angeli, C., "On the Nature of the π → π* Ionic Excited States: The V State of Ethene as a Prototype". J. Comput. Chem. 2009, 30, 1319-1333. doi: 10.1002/jcc.21155
(4) Wu, W.; Zhang, H.; Braïda, B.; Shaik, S.; Hiberty, P., "The V state of ethylene: valence bond theory takes up the challenge". Theor. Chem. Acc. 2014, 133, 1-13.doi: 10.1007/s00214-013-1441-x



This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
Enhanced by Zemanta