Classical solution of the FeMo-cofactor model to chemical accuracy and its implications

Huanchen Zhai, Chenghan Li, Xing Zhang, Zhendong Li, Seunghoon Lee, and Garnet Kin-Lic Chan (2026)
Highlighted by Jan Jensen

The FeMo cofactor in nitrogenase enzymes is often mentioned as the killer application of quantum computing (QC) in chemistry. That is due to its complex electronic structure, which has made is difficult to model accurately. However, Chan and co-workers now claim to have computed the electronic energy to, by their estimate, chemical accuracy by conventional means.

They have done so by a series of calculations as indicated in the figure above. The CPU requirements are not given in detail, but the authors point out that no supercomputer was needed. 

Interestingly, the authors found that the ground state wavefunction is not inherently strongly multireference. Rather the main challenge is to identify the correct (mostly) single-reference state.

Where does that leave chemical applications of QC? For one thing, it moves the goalpost further back. The active space is the one typically used to estimate QC requirements, but it may have to be expanded to include MOs from the surrounding protein to accurately capture the chemistry, which would require even larger quantum computer. But that will be even further into the future with plenty of time for conventional approached to get there first. 

In my opinion, the case for QC-based quantum chemistry was never very strong, and this study is just another blow.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.